Shopify checkout optimisation: 9 changes that raise conversion rate

Most Shopify stores can sell more without a new theme. They need fewer reasons for a buyer to stop between the cart and the payment. The nine changes below take those reasons away: show costs early, offer the payment method people already use, ask for less, and follow up with the ones who leave. Together they usually move checkout completion by several points, which lowers your cost per order without touching the ad budget.
In short
- Measure first: started checkouts against completed checkouts over the last 30 days.
- Before checkout: show shipping costs early, set a free shipping threshold just above your average order, never force an account.
- In checkout: express payment first, the local payment method per country, fewer fields.
- After: language and currency per market, trust details near the total, an abandoned checkout message within the hour.
- Every point of checkout completion lowers your cost per order without touching the ad budget.
Where does a Shopify checkout lose people?
Before you change anything, look at three numbers in Shopify Analytics for the last 30 days: sessions that added to cart, sessions that reached checkout, and sessions that completed checkout. This article is about the drop between "reached checkout" and "completed". For most DTC stores we audit, between 40% and 60% of started checkouts finish. Below 45% there is almost always something specific to fix.
The causes are predictable, and research keeps finding the same ones. The Baymard Institute, which collects checkout studies, puts the average documented cart abandonment rate at about 70%. Among shoppers who meant to buy, the reason given most often is extra costs that were too high (40%), and 18% left because the site wanted them to create an account. In a store, that means shipping costs that appear for the first time on the shipping step, or a missing local payment method. It also means a form that asks for a company name, a second address line and a phone number nobody wants to give, and no follow-up when someone simply gets distracted.
Shopify's own checkout is fast and well tested, so there is nothing to redesign. The work is configuring it well and fixing what happens around it.
Changes 1 to 3: remove the surprises before checkout
1. Show shipping costs on the product page and in the cart. Unexpected costs are the most common reason people abandon. A line under the price such as "Free delivery in the Netherlands from €60, otherwise €4.95" takes the surprise away before it happens. If you offer free shipping, say so everywhere. If you do not, state the price.
2. Set a free shipping threshold just above your average order value. With an average order of €52, a threshold of €60 nudges a share of buyers into adding a second item. Set it far above the average and it does nothing. Set it below and you give away margin on orders that would have happened anyway. Show progress in the cart: "Add €8 for free delivery."
3. Never force an account. In Settings, under Customer accounts, make sure buyers can check out as a guest. Sign-in can stay available for returning customers. But requiring an account before payment is a reliable way to lose first-time buyers, and those are the people your ads are paying for.
Changes 4 to 6: inside the checkout
4. Turn on express checkout and put it first. Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay let a buyer pay in one or two taps with saved details. On mobile, where most paid social traffic lands, this is the change that does the most. Check that the express buttons also appear in the cart and, if your theme supports it, on the product page.
5. Offer the local payment method. Dutch buyers expect iDEAL, Belgians Bancontact and the French Cartes Bancaires, and many shoppers across Europe use Klarna or PayPal. If your store sells across borders, check in Shopify Payments or your payment provider that each market shows its own method at the top. A buyer who does not see the method they trust will often leave rather than type in card details.
6. Ask for less. In Settings, under Checkout, set the company name and the second address line to hidden or optional, and keep the phone number optional unless your carrier truly needs it. Leave address autocomplete on. Each field you remove is one less moment to hesitate on a small phone screen.
Changes 7 to 9: the details that decide the last 10%
7. Match language and currency to the buyer. A Dutch visitor who lands on an English checkout in euros with a UK-style address form will hesitate. Shopify Markets lets you set language, currency and payment methods per country. If you sell in the Netherlands, Belgium and France, buyers in each country should see a checkout in their own language and currency.
8. Repeat the reasons to trust you. Above or near the order summary, show the expected delivery date, the returns policy in one line ("30 days, free returns") and the payment options. On Shopify Plus you can add these as checkout UI extensions. On other plans, put them in the cart and on the product page, which is where the decision really forms.
9. Follow up on abandoned checkouts within the hour. Shopify keeps the details of every checkout where an email or phone number was entered. Send the first reminder 30 to 60 minutes later, a second one the next day, and stop there. In most stores we see, a plain message with the product photo and a direct link back to the filled-in checkout does better than a discount. Keep discounts for the second message, if you use them at all.
A worked example
Illustrative figures, not a client result.
Take a fashion brand, as an illustration, with an average order of €75. It spends €40,000 a month on Meta and Google ads, and 4,000 checkouts are started each month. Of those, 52% complete, which gives the store 2,080 orders at an ad cost per order of about €19.20.
Then express checkout moves to the top, iDEAL and Bancontact show first for their markets, the phone and company fields go optional, shipping costs appear on the product page, and an abandoned checkout flow goes live. Completion rises to 60%. That is 2,400 orders from the same 4,000 checkouts, or 320 more orders and roughly €24,000 more revenue in a month. The ad budget did not change, so cost per order falls to about €16.70.
That 13% drop in cost per order is room you can spend on more ads, which is why we fix the checkout before we scale the budget. We apply the same logic when we set an ad budget from margin and target cost per order.
Checklist: what a healthy Shopify checkout looks like
- Checkout completion above 50% over the last 30 days, checked monthly.
- Shipping costs visible on the product page and in the cart.
- A free shipping threshold 10% to 20% above the average order value.
- Guest checkout allowed, with no account required to pay.
- Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay active and shown first.
- The local payment method shown first in each market.
- Company name and second address line hidden or optional, and phone optional.
- Language, currency and address format matched per market.
- Delivery date and returns policy visible before the buyer pays.
- An abandoned checkout flow with two messages, the first within the hour.
- Pixel and Conversions API both recording purchases, so your advertising is optimised on real orders.
If you are building or rebuilding a store, these settings belong in the first version rather than a later optimisation round. That is part of how we approach Shopify websites, because a checkout that converts 8 points better is the cheapest growth most stores will ever buy.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good checkout completion rate on Shopify?
In the stores we audit, between 40% and 60% of started checkouts are completed. Below 45% there is almost always a specific cause to fix, and above 55% the checkout is in good shape.
Why do people abandon a Shopify checkout?
The usual reasons are extra costs that appear late, a required account, a missing local payment method, too many form fields, and simple distraction. Each one has a setting or a message that fixes it.
Does Shop Pay increase conversion?
Express methods such as Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay let returning buyers pay in one or two taps, which matters most on mobile. Turn them on and show them first, including in the cart.
Which payment methods should a store in the Netherlands, Belgium and France offer?
Offer iDEAL in the Netherlands, Bancontact in Belgium and Cartes Bancaires in France, each shown first in its own market. Add cards, PayPal and a pay-later option such as Klarna.
Can I customise the Shopify checkout without Shopify Plus?
Yes, for everything in this article. Fields, accounts, payment methods, markets and abandoned checkout emails can be changed on every plan. Adding custom blocks inside the checkout itself needs Shopify Plus.
When should I send an abandoned checkout email?
Send the first within 30 to 60 minutes and a second the next day, then stop. A plain reminder with the product and a link back to the filled-in checkout usually beats a discount.

