AIGENCYFLOW

How to choose an e-commerce media buying agency: 12 questions to ask

Choose an e-commerce media buying agency on four things you can check before you sign: who actually runs your account, how new ads get made and tested, what number they are judged on, and who owns the accounts and the data. Case studies and logos only tell you an agency has had good clients. The twelve questions below show how your own account will be run on an ordinary Tuesday.

In short

  • Ask to meet the person who will run your account, not only the person who sells it.
  • For online stores, the creative process matters more than the campaign setup. Ask how many new ads you get each week and who makes them.
  • Agree one number: a target cost per order that comes from your margin.
  • Ad accounts, pixels, audiences and creatives must stay in your name.
  • Prefer a monthly contract and a fee that does not grow just because your spend grows.

Before you talk to any agency: know three numbers

You can only judge an agency against a target, and the target comes from you.

  • Average order value.
  • Contribution margin per order, after product cost, shipping, payment fees and returns.
  • What a customer is worth over a year, if people reorder.

From those you can set a target cost per order, the most you can pay in ads to win one order. If you do not have it yet, this article shows how to work it out. It is a good sign when an agency opens the first call by asking for these numbers. Opening with its own awards is not.

The team: who does the work?

1. Who will run my account day to day, and can I talk to them? Look for a named person with years in the platforms who joins the call. The usual failure is a senior person who sells and a junior who runs ten accounts behind an account manager.

2. How many accounts does that person manage? There is no perfect figure. Someone with a handful of accounts can look at yours every day, though, and someone with twenty-five cannot.

3. Which e-commerce accounts like mine have you run? Go beyond sector and ask about price point, margin and market. A store selling €40 products with repeat orders is run differently from one selling €900 products once.

Badges deserve a short note. Partner programmes such as Google Partner check that an agency meets the platform's minimums, which for Google means a level of ad spend, an optimisation score and certified staff. A badge shows the agency is real and active. It tells you nothing about how your account will be run.

The method: how are ads made and tested?

4. Who makes the ads, and how many new ones do I get each week? On Meta and TikTok the ad decides most of the result, which makes this the most important question on the list. A clear answer has a number and a rhythm: a batch of new creatives on a fixed day, sized to your spend. Our rule of thumb for that number is in how many new creatives a week you need.

5. How do you decide an ad has won or lost? Look for a rule set in advance, such as judging an ad once it has spent about three times the target cost per order. "We look at the data" is not a rule.

6. What do you check before spending anything? The right answer is tracking, meaning the pixel, the Conversions API, the product feed and whether orders in the ad platform match orders in the store. An agency that launches in week one without that check is optimising on numbers nobody has verified.

7. Which platform would you start with, and why? For most stores it should be one platform first, usually Meta, with Google Shopping added to catch the people who then search for you. A proposal with five platforms from day one spreads a small budget too thin to learn anything. We explain the Google side in Google Shopping vs Performance Max.

The numbers: what are you judged on?

8. Which number do you report on? For a store it should be orders, cost per order and, where you share your margins, profit. Return on ad spend is useful but easy to flatter with retargeting and branded search. Reach, clicks and click-through rate help with diagnosis but are not results.

9. What does the weekly report look like? Can I see a real one? Ask for an anonymised example. It should say what was spent, what came back, what was tested, what was learned and what will change next week, in language you can read without a glossary.

10. What happens in a bad month? Every account has one. A good answer describes a routine: check tracking, check the store, check creative fatigue, hold the budget, change the ads. A bad one blames the algorithm or asks for more budget.

The contract: what am I signing?

11. Who owns the ad accounts, the pixel and the creatives? You do. The agency should work inside your Business Manager and your ad accounts with partner access, and every creative it makes should be yours to keep. When the account belongs to the agency, leaving means starting from zero.

12. How do you charge, and how long am I tied in? The usual models are a percentage of ad spend, a fixed monthly fee, or a fixed fee with a performance part. A percentage rewards the agency for spending more. A fixed fee rewards it for doing the agreed work. You should always pay the ad spend yourself, directly to the platform. A monthly contract keeps both sides honest, while a twelve-month lock-in protects only the agency.

Warning signs

  • Guaranteed results: a promised return, a promised number of orders, or "first place". Nobody controls the auction.
  • A proposal with no questions about your margin.
  • Reports built on reach, impressions and clicks.
  • The agency insists on running ads from its own ad account.
  • No clear answer on who makes the ads.
  • Results shown without a period, a spend level or a market.
  • Pressure to raise the budget before cost per order is under target.

A simple way to compare two agencies

Give both the same brief: your three numbers, read-only access to your ad account, and two weeks. Ask each for a one-page plan saying what they would change first, what they would test in the first month, and what they would need from you. This is about seeing how they think and should not turn into free work. The better agency is usually the one whose plan is more specific and makes fewer promises.

Checklist to take into the call

  • I know my average order value, margin and target cost per order.
  • I have met the person who will run the account.
  • I know how many new ads I get each week and who makes them.
  • Tracking is checked before budget moves.
  • Reporting is weekly, in writing, on orders and cost per order.
  • Accounts, data and creatives stay mine.
  • The contract is monthly, and ad spend is paid directly to the platform.

These are the terms we work on ourselves. You can see how we run paid advertising for e-commerce brands, and our plain guide explains what a media buying agency is in the first place.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for in an e-commerce media buying agency?

Look for four things: an experienced person running your account, a weekly process for making and testing new ads, reporting on orders and cost per order, and ad accounts that stay in your name. Sector experience helps, though method counts for more.

How much ad spend do I need before hiring a media buying agency?

Enough that the fee is small next to the improvement you can expect. A rough test is whether a 20% lower cost per order would pay the agency fee several times over. If it would not, wait, and fix your offer and checkout first.

Should a media buying agency guarantee results?

No. An agency controls its work. It does not control the auction, your product or your prices. Treat any guaranteed return or ranking as a warning sign. What an agency can promise is a process, a rhythm and honest reporting.

Is it better to hire a specialist e-commerce agency or a general marketing agency?

For paid ads on a store, a specialist is usually better, because product feeds, catalogue campaigns, checkout tracking and creative testing are specific skills. A general agency suits brands that mainly need branding, content or PR.

How long should I give a new agency before judging it?

About two to three months. Expect roughly three weeks of learning and a month of stabilising before cost per order settles. Judge the process from week one and the numbers from month three.

Can I keep my creatives and data if I leave?

You should be able to. Check that the contract says ad accounts, pixels, audiences and every creative made for you remain yours.

Sources

Let’s talk about your project.

Book 30 minutes with the founder. We prepare the call by looking at your ads and your website beforehand.

Yousrireplies in under 30 min

  1. We look at your numbers
  2. We tell you what we’d change
  3. Quote within 48h
  • 30-minute video call
  • No commitment

Prefer to write? Message on WhatsApp

Do you run a gym?Free audit with the founder

Live calendar30-min video call, email confirmation