Media buying agency, marketing agency or in-house: which does your brand need?
A media buying agency runs your paid ads. A marketing agency covers the wider mix of brand, content, email, SEO and often ads as well, and an in-house media buyer does the ads from inside your team. For most online stores that already sell and want to grow through paid ads, a specialised media buying agency that also makes the creatives is the best fit. A full-service marketing agency suits brands whose main problem is positioning or content. An in-house buyer starts to make sense once ad spend is large and steady enough to fill a senior person's week.
In short
- "Marketing agency" is the broad term. "Media buying agency" is the specialist for paid ads.
- Pick by your bottleneck. Choose a specialist if it is paid acquisition and a generalist if it is brand or content.
- A freelancer is good value at lower spend, with the risk of one person being ill or busy.
- In-house gives focus and speed, and costs a salary, tools and a creative team around it.
- Many brands combine them: in-house for brand and email, an agency for paid ads and creatives.
What each option actually is
Media buying agency. A team that plans, buys and manages paid advertising on Meta, Google, TikTok and similar platforms. The good ones for e-commerce also produce the ads. We describe the work in what is a media buying agency.
Full-service marketing agency. One agency for strategy, branding, content, social media, email, SEO, website and advertising. It is broad, so by nature less deep in each area.
Freelance media buyer. One specialist who manages the ad accounts of a few clients, often someone who used to work at an agency or in-house.
In-house media buyer. An employee who runs your ads full-time. To be effective they usually need designers, editors and an analyst nearby.
Side by side
| Media buying agency | Full-service marketing agency | Freelance media buyer | In-house media buyer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | Paid ads, often with creatives | Whole marketing mix | Paid ads | Paid ads for one brand |
| Depth in paid ads | High | Varies, often medium | High, in one or two platforms | High once hired well |
| Creative production | Often included | Usually included, slower rhythm | Rarely | Needs a separate team |
| Sees other accounts | Yes, many | Yes, mixed sectors | A few | No |
| Speed of change | Days | Weeks | Days | Hours |
| Continuity | Team backup | Team backup | One person | Depends on one hire |
| Cost shape | Monthly fee | Larger monthly fee or project | Lower monthly fee | Salary plus tools and creatives |
| Best when | Paid ads are the growth engine | Brand and content are the gap | Spend is modest | Spend is large and stable |
How to choose: start from your bottleneck
Ask what would change your numbers most in the next six months.
- "Our ads work, but cost per order keeps creeping up." That is a creative and testing problem. You need a media buying agency with in-house creative, or a creative partner next to your own buyer.
- "We have a good product and little demand." Paid social creates demand fastest, so a media buying agency, starting on one platform.
- "People visit and do not buy." That is a store problem, not an ads problem. Fix the product page and checkout first. See Shopify checkout optimisation.
- "Nobody knows who we are or why we are different." That is positioning. Bring in a brand or full-service agency before you scale ads.
- "We depend entirely on paid ads." Add channels that do not charge per click, namely email and SEO. Either a generalist or a specialist per channel can do that.
When does an in-house media buyer make sense?
Hiring in-house is attractive. You get one person, fully focused on your brand and in your team chat. It works when three things are true.
- There is enough work. Ad spend is high and steady across the year, so a senior buyer has a full week.
- You can feed them. A buyer without a steady supply of new ads is like a chef without ingredients. You need creative production, in-house or bought in.
- You can judge them. Someone in the company understands the accounts well enough to know whether the work is good.
The risks come from the same place. When that person leaves, the knowledge goes too. An in-house buyer also sees only your account, so they notice platform changes later than a team that sees many. A common middle route is an in-house marketer who owns the strategy and the numbers, with an agency doing the buying and the creatives.
When is a full-service marketing agency the better choice?
Choose the generalist when your needs really are spread out: a rebrand, a new website, a content calendar, PR and some advertising, with nobody in-house to coordinate specialists. One contract and one contact are worth something then.
What you give up is depth. In a full-service agency, paid ads are one department among many, and e-commerce specifics such as product feeds, catalogue campaigns and server-side tracking may not be daily work. If most of your marketing budget goes to ad spend, the team spending it should be specialists.
Can you combine them?
Yes, and most growing brands do. A split that works:
- You: product, pricing, brand voice, customer service, email.
- Media buying agency: paid ads, creatives, tracking and the weekly report.
- Specialists when needed: SEO, a store rebuild, photography.
To keep this from becoming chaos, agree on one target cost per order and one source of truth for the numbers, and fix one weekly moment where everyone looks at the same report.
Checklist: which one fits you?
- Paid ads are, or should be, more than half of new customer growth: media buying agency.
- The main gaps are brand, content and website: full-service marketing agency.
- Ad spend is modest and you want a specialist: freelance media buyer.
- Ad spend is large and steady, and you have creative production: in-house.
- You are unsure: start with a monthly contract with a specialist, and revisit after three months.
If the first line describes you, this is how we run paid advertising and ad creatives in one team. The questions to ask any agency, including us, are in how to choose an e-commerce media buying agency.
Frequently asked questions
Is a media buying agency the same as a marketing agency?
No. A media buying agency specialises in paid advertising, while a marketing agency is broader and may include branding, content, email, SEO and web design. Some marketing agencies have a media buying team inside them.
Is a media buying agency the same as a performance marketing agency?
Largely, yes. "Performance marketing" means marketing judged on measurable results, and paid ads are its core. Agencies use both labels for similar work, along with "paid social agency" and "Meta ads agency".
Should I hire a media buyer in-house or use an agency?
Use an agency while spend is growing and you need creative production and backup. Hire in-house once spend is large and steady, you can supply new ads every week, and someone in the company can judge the work.
Is a freelancer cheaper than an agency?
Usually the fee is lower, because there is less overhead. In exchange you get less backup, and you normally have to arrange creatives yourself. For a store with modest spend it can be the right choice.
Can a marketing agency run my Meta and Google ads well?
Some can. Ask who runs the account, how many e-commerce accounts they manage, and how new ads are made and tested. Those answers tell you more than the agency's label.

